Asked a company to delete your data and heard nothing? What a new GDPR fine shows
Italy fined a retailer for ignoring a deletion request sent to its general inbox. Here's how the GDPR right to erasure works and what to do when you're ignored.

Most people have done it at least once: you email a company asking it to delete your data and stop messaging you, get an automatic "thanks, we've received your message" — and then nothing. A few months later, the promotional texts start again.
A decision published by the European Data Protection Board on 10 November shows that this isn't just annoying. It can be a breach of the GDPR, and regulators will act on it. This post explains what happened, what the right to erasure actually gives you, and how to make a deletion request that's hard to ignore.
What happened in the Italian case
According to the decision of Italy's data protection authority, the Garante, a customer of the clothing company Barbuti S.p.A. emailed the company in June 2024 asking for their personal data to be deleted. The promotional text messages they'd been receiving didn't say how to exercise data protection rights, so they used the company's general contact address. They got an automatic acknowledgement, but no real answer — and the marketing messages kept coming, with the last one recorded in January 2026.
The company told the Garante it was an internal mix-up: the request had landed in an inbox used for e-commerce and general questions, nobody was assigned to monitor it for privacy requests, and so it was never logged. The Garante wasn't persuaded. In its decision of 23 September 2026, it found that the company:
- had no adequate procedure to handle data protection requests arriving through its own contact channels;
- failed to respond to the erasure request and kept sending marketing messages without a valid legal basis;
- sent promotional messages that didn't include a way to exercise your rights, as Italian law requires.
It fined the company €5,000 and ordered it to fix its marketing practices and report back within 30 days. The fine is small — the Garante took into account that this was negligence rather than intent, and that the company fixed the problem and cooperated. But the reasoning matters far more than the amount.
This isn't a one-off problem
Earlier this year the EDPB published the results of a Europe-wide check on how organisations handle deletion requests. Throughout 2025, 32 data protection authorities investigated the topic and 764 organisations answered their questionnaire. The EDPB calls the right to erasure one of the most frequently exercised data protection rights, and rated overall compliance as only "average".
The first issue on its list of seven recurring problems was exactly what went wrong in the Italian case: no documented internal procedure to handle erasure requests. Others included poorly trained staff, too little information given to people about their rights, and misuse of the legal exceptions to refuse requests. In other words, if a company ignores your request, the most likely reason is a broken process — not that you did something wrong.
What the right to erasure gives you
Article 17 of the GDPR, often called the right to be forgotten, says an organisation must delete your personal data without undue delay when one of several grounds applies. The ones most people rely on are:
- the data is no longer needed for the purpose it was collected for;
- you gave consent and you've withdrawn it, and there's no other legal basis;
- you object to the processing and the organisation has no overriding legitimate grounds;
- you object to your data being used for direct marketing;
- the data was processed unlawfully in the first place.
Marketing is the simplest case. Under Article 21, you can object to direct marketing at any time, and when you do, your data may no longer be used for that purpose. The company doesn't get to weigh its interests against yours.
The right isn't absolute. An organisation can keep data it is legally required to hold — invoices for tax purposes, for example — or that it needs for legal claims, and there are exceptions for freedom of expression, public health, and archiving or research in the public interest. But it has to explain which exception it's relying on. Silence is not an answer.
The deadlines a company must meet
Article 12 of the GDPR sets the rules for how organisations respond to any rights request, including deletion:
- They must act without undue delay and within one month of receiving your request.
- They can extend that by two more months for complex or numerous requests, but they must tell you within the first month and explain why.
- If they decide not to act, they must tell you within one month, give their reasons and tell you that you can complain to a data protection authority or go to court.
- It's free. They can only charge a fee or refuse if a request is manifestly unfounded or excessive, and they have to prove that.
- If they have reasonable doubts about who you are, they can ask for information to confirm your identity — but only what's necessary.
How to make a deletion request that's hard to ignore
Use the privacy contact if you can find it
Look in the privacy notice for a data protection officer or privacy email address. The Italian decision shows a general contact address can count too — but the privacy contact is the fastest route to someone who knows what to do.
Put it in writing and be clear
Say that you're making a request under Article 17 GDPR to erase your personal data, and, if they market to you, that you also object to direct marketing under Article 21. Include the details they need to find you — the email address or phone number they contact you on — but don't send more personal data than necessary.
Say what you want erased
All your data, or specific things such as your phone number on a marketing list or a profile page.
Keep a record
Save a copy of your email and the date you sent it, plus any automatic acknowledgement. Screenshot any marketing messages you receive afterwards — they're evidence.
Diary the deadline
Note the date one month after you sent the request. If you hear nothing by then, send a short reminder pointing to the deadline in Article 12.
Complain if you're still ignored
You can lodge a complaint with your national data protection authority, such as the Garante in Italy or the CNIL in France. Your saved emails and screenshots are exactly what they'll ask for.
Why this matters beyond marketing texts
Unwanted promotional messages are the everyday version of this problem. The more serious version is your name, phone number and home address sitting on people-search sites, data broker lists and online directories. That combination is what scammers use to make a phishing text or a fake support call sound believable, and what makes doxxing and stalking easier.
The same rights apply there. If a site publishes your personal data and it falls under the GDPR, you can ask it to erase that data — and the same rules on deadlines, explanations and complaints apply. In practice, the hard part is often finding all the places your data appears, then finding each site's privacy contact and keeping track of who has answered.
Where BetterPrivacy fits in
BetterPrivacy finds pages that publish your personal data — people-search sites, data brokers, directories, forums and news archives — and ranks them by how sensitive they are. For each one, it finds the site's privacy contact and prepares a GDPR or CCPA removal request for you to review and send, then tracks which pages come down and alerts you if your data reappears. No service can force every site to comply, but a clear request sent to the right contact, with a record of when you sent it, gives you the best chance — and the evidence you need if you have to complain.
A free scan shows your top 3 results in full, so you can see where your personal data is published today.
Three things you can do today
- Pick the company whose marketing messages annoy you most and send a written erasure request and marketing objection today.
- Start a simple note or folder for every rights request you send: who, when, and what they replied.
- Run a free BetterPrivacy scan to see which sites publish your name next to your phone number or address.
Sources
- Italian DPA fines clothing company for failing to handle erasure request (10 November 2026) — European Data Protection Board
- Decision against Barbuti S.p.A. of 23 September 2026 [doc. web n. 10312650] (in Italian) — Garante per la protezione dei dati personali (Italy)
- CEF 2025 report: implementation of the right to erasure by controllers — European Data Protection Board
- DPC welcomes publication of EDPB CEF implementation report on right to be forgotten (20 February 2026) — Data Protection Commission (Ireland)
- Art. 17 GDPR – Right to erasure ('right to be forgotten') — gdpr-info.eu (text of Regulation (EU) 2016/679)
- Art. 21 GDPR – Right to object — gdpr-info.eu (text of Regulation (EU) 2016/679)
- Art. 12 GDPR – Transparent information, communication and modalities for the exercise of the rights of the data subject — gdpr-info.eu (text of Regulation (EU) 2016/679)
- Your right to get your data deleted — UK Information Commissioner's Office